I laughed a lot at a very sad funeral this week. Emotions, eh. I’m hopeful this weird juxta-positioning of emotions is a kind of human coping strategy, rather than a sociopathic tell. Then again, the mourning crowd laughed at the brilliant life narration too. Back at my desk, a flurry of headlines hitting the screen prompted a further emotional conflict. Surging extreme weather events globally, Europe battered by tariff tyranny, Gaza starved and Ukrainian cities terrorised by Russian bombardment are hardly sources of optimism for the progress of our species. And, yet……I’m picking up a very euphoric vibe from the financial markets. Strangely for this publication, I’m not that interested in retro-fitting the euphoria with some financial rationale along the lines of falling cost of money(rates), corporate earnings, tech innovation or economic cycles. The sheer phenomenon of financial euphoria is worth highlighting first. Then we can do some thinking, all of us. Now for the euphoria…..
The “wisdom of crowds” leans on the idea that large groups of people (markets) are collectively more likely to be correct than individual experts. What is particularly striking about current financial market behaviours is that there is a wide variety of “crowds” ignoring the gloom-filled headlines and seeing a better future out there. However, that optimism is not exactly a new phenomenon. Note that financial markets typically enjoy positive returns in seven out of every ten years. In other words, it pays off to be relatively optimistic. However, in this piece we are looking at something more, evidence of euphoric excess. Let’s try a few of these crowds for starters…..
*The crypto crowd: Bitcoin is hitting record highs of $118,000 while the entire crypto ecosystem has now surpassed $4 trillion in value.
*The IT crowd: If one uses pre-2018 sector classifications, then technology stocks’ weighting in the S&P 500 is above 45%. That’s way higher than the dotcom bubble of 2000.
*The ‘Magnificent 7’ crowd: There’s now, not one, but two Big Tech companies with market values in excess of $4 trillion. For context (and wobbly comparison), the $8 trillion combination of Microsoft and Nvidia alone would rank 3rd globally as a single country GDP.
*The meme-stock crowd: In 2021 it was Gamestop and the Robinhood day-traders. Now, it’s Kohl,’s (retail) Krispy Kreme(donuts) OpenDoor (estate agent) and American Eagle with Sydney Sweeney dominating social media, chat rooms and…. Wall Street trading volumes.
*The AI/Cloud crowd: Earlier in the year Microsoft CEO, Satya Nadella, in a Davos interview stated he “was good for $80 billion of investment in 2025” in AI/Cloud infrastructure. Scratch that. This week he said the number will be $120 billion. Google said $85 billion (up from $75 billion) as Big Tech companies look like they will do a giddy AI spend of close to $400 billion in 2025.
*The M&A crowd: Research data from Pitchbook shows robust merger and acquisition (M&A) activity in Q2, marking the third consecutive quarter for deal value to hit about $1 trillion across roughly 12,000 transactions. It’s not just tech showing confidence. Railway giants Norfolk Southern and Union Pacific are doing an $85 billion merger to create the first transcontinental railway line in US history.
*The retail crowd: Barclays research points to retail investors as the “primary driver” of the recent stock market rally. In the past month alone, retail investors poured $50 billion into US stocks and now account for up to 20% of daily trading volume on Wall Street. That’s double the levels seen before the pandemic.
*The VC crowd: The challenged venture capital (VC) world has been looking for a genuine positive pulse-take via an IPO exit. As I write, Greylock Partners, Sequoia and Index Venture will be the VCs doing cartwheels tonight after the largest VC-backed tech IPO in years, Figma, tripled in value within hours of its NYSE debut to almost $50 billion. Or… will they be wondering how they got the selling (IPO) price so wrong?
It is entirely possible many of the above trends are rooted in fundamental investment theses but suggestions of dangerous “euphoria” can be found in aggregate valuations of US stocks. The average price/sales valuation multiple (per Bloomberg) for US stocks is a punchy 3.3x. Furthermore, Warren Buffett’s favoured sanity check of comparing the market value(cap) of all publicly traded US companies with total US GDP currently stands at 212%. As a risk guide, Warren is usually uneasy when that number is over 100%. My own two personal favourites in the euphoria beauty parade are more esoteric but tell their own stories.
First, it is no secret Facebook/Meta and others in the AI “arms race” are desperately looking for AI talent. However, the numbers are starting to look bonkers. According to Wired magazine, at least one prospective employee was offered a 3-year billion dollar salary package to join Meta. Others were offered hundreds of millions (rumoured to be Mira Murati’s Thinking Machines Lab team) but here’s the best bit…. the prospective hires turned down the offers!! Now, here’s a few other proposals that were turned down as recently as November 2022.
If that date sounds familiar, you might have been vowing to stay away from markets at the time as stocks hit bear market lows spooked by rising global interest rates. Online car retailer, Carvana, was “on sale” that day after its share price had collapsed by almost 99% from its highs the previous year. Nobody wanted to touch it. As of today, it’s up more than 10,000% since then. Fear and greed, emotions eh. Oh, and Meta’s share price on that day after a rough year for the Zuck was $88.91 per share. It’s up almost 800% since then but here’s the best bit….in barely one trading session after its excellent quarterly results this week, Meta’s share price jumped by about $88.91 per share. That number sound familiar?
No more teasing. The key point is that confidence is surging in public markets. The quieter, less public private markets have struggled to generate similar headlines. Yes, there are pockets of excess. However, it would be foolish to ignore the ‘wisdom’ of the public market crowds. Ultimately, higher trading activity levels, record capex investment, big M&A deals and higher valuations will feed into private markets and smaller companies. Indeed, you might have to get used to the giddy headlines for a bit longer. Goldman Sachs have done a bit of historical analysis and concluded that spikes in speculative trading actually precede abnormally high returns on a one-year time horizon. Don’t stay too long at the beach….the YOLO crowd might be on to something.
N.H. RIP
